fbpx

Queensland barrister guilty of professional misconduct, no longer practicing family law

Queensland barrister guilty of professional misconduct, no longer practicing family law

By Naomi Neilson|25 September 2019

 

A Gold Coast barrister will no longer practice family law and was ordered to complete 12 months of readership after being found guilty of professional misconduct.

Patricia Merkin has been publicly reprimanded and ordered to pay applicant’s costs to the discipline application after she persistently pursued empty appeals in Full Family Court and refused to admit any professional lapses until the last minute.

The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal noted: “The conduct under each of the charges was not a momentary fleeting lapse of judgement. Rather, in each case, it involved a wilful and persistent course of action by the respondent which was inimical to the respondent’s paramount duty to the administration of justice.”

During an appeal against final parenting orders, Ms Merkin insisted a written transcript of the hearing did not accurately reflect an incident during the hearing and concluded an audio recording had been tampered with, going so far as to blame the trial judge.

Advertisement

 

 

 

Advertisement

Despite her client listening to the audio and ascertaining there was no issue found in the written transcript, Ms Merkin pursued the argument and filed for appeal.

The Full Family Court said: “The particular concern that we have about the conduct of Ms Merkin is despite the mother in effect no longer pursuing the claim the transcript had been edited or amended, her counsel pursued both claims, and most troubling, has suggested that the trial judge may have been involved in this.”

4696187107628090330.gif

 

When the Bar Association of Queensland investigated the behaviour, Ms Merkin said the unfounded tampering is “a matter of great and critical importance” and it was her duty to raise it. She went so far as to characterise herself as a “whistleblower”.

Under cross-examination before the Tribunal, Ms Merkin maintained there was never any professional lapse on her part. She maintained this innocence until the end.

“It was only in the course of closing submissions, after counsel for the Law Services Commission (LSC) had addressed the Tribunal, that the penny seemed to drop with the respondent that her conduct in these matters had involved a serious departure from the standards expected of counsel,” the Tribunal said in their decision.

SPONSORED CONTENT

 

1888188786714548349.jpg

The ‘new normal’ is digital

 

 

8084496998334551275.jpg

Who are Lawyers Weekly’s 30 Under 30 2020 winners?

 

In another instance, Ms Merkin argued the judge in another family court matter made her decision based on her own research, rather than evidence.

“When questioned by the court, she was unable to articulate how the ground could be supported, nor could she identify any part of the trial judge’s reasons or orders which demonstrated or supported the proposition that the trial judge had acted on her own research rather than the evidence,” the Tribunal noted.

The Full Family Court said her argument was “devoid of merit” and lacking foundation, which raised serious concerns about Ms Merkin’s conduct in advancing it at all.

“It is clear that the respondent’s conduct was discreditable for a barrister and was likely to diminish public confidence in the administration of justice,” the Tribunal said.

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Big Law

 

0 Comments

 

 

 

  • There are no comments yet.

 

BREAKING NEWS

Be the first to hear the latest developments across the legal profession

SIGN UP

LATEST

 

$49.5m NAB class action insurance settlement approved

 

30u30 community legal centre lawyer finalists revealed

 

30u30 taxation finalists revealed

 

‘Volatility is becoming normalised’ for insurance lawyers

RELATED ARTICLES

 

$49.5m NAB class action insurance settlement approved

 

30u30 community legal centre lawyer finalists revealed

 

30u30 taxation finalists revealed

 

‘Volatility is becoming normalised’ for insurance lawyers

 

Completing deals in the age of COVID-19

 

Informing in 2020: Victoria Police tighten obligations around lawyer informants

FROM THE WEB

Recommended by Spike Native Network

getad.img.jpg

nestegg

Moving overseas? Check your tax status first

1__#$!@!#__getad.img.jpg

Get Jarvis

Meet Jarvis, your local, trusted housekeeping service

2__#$!@!#__getad.img.jpg

Australian Aviation

Canberra airport expansion will see passenger numbers treble

3__#$!@!#__getad.img.jpg

Smart Property Investment

The 5 ways property helps you achieve financial freedom

 

 

 

 

Find your dream job.

 

Select Category

Banking and Finance Law

Construction Law

Corporate and Commercial Law

Criminal and Civil Law

Environment and Planning Law

Family Law

Generalists - In House

Generalists - Law Firm

Industrial Relations and Employment Law

Insurance and Superannuation Law

Intellectual Property Law

Law Clerks and Paralegals

Legal Practice Management

Legal Secretaries

Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Personal Injury Law

Property Law

Tax Law

Other

SEARCH

MOST READ

‘Informer 3838’: The real story behind Lawyer X

Law student seeks $64k in damages against admission board

One decision does not make an entire justice system

How mid-tiers are reacting to COVID-19

Firms should be deeply ashamed of cuts to employee remuneration

 

 

Why we’ll keep delivering for our communities in the face of COVID-19

As Australia tries to keep pace with a rapidly changing business and social landscape in the wake of COVID-19, Momentum Media is leading the way delivering essential content to our communities, writes Alex Whitlock, director of Lawyers Weekly.

Read more

LATEST STORIES

 

BIG LAW

$49.5m NAB class action insurance settlement approved

 

BIG LAW

30u30 community legal centre lawyer finalists revealed

 

BIG LAW

30u30 taxation finalists revealed

 

BIG LAW

‘Volatility is becoming normalised’ for insurance lawyers

 

BIG LAW

Completing deals in the age of COVID-19

 

<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1403433286431701&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1"> <img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=634919500281408&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

 

 

 

OUR PLATFORMS AND BRANDS

 

EVENTS AND SUMMITS

 

USEFUL LINKS

 

CATEGORIES

SIGN UP

You must be logged in to comment due to spam issues.